Is AI Why New Grads Can't Find Jobs? Vanguard Says Look Elsewhere.
A new analysis points to slow hiring overall, not chatbots, as the main reason young college graduates are struggling.
BusinessRecent college graduates have had a rough time breaking into the workforce, and artificial intelligence often gets the blame. A new analysis from investment firm Vanguard argues that's mostly the wrong culprit.
Vanguard senior economist Adam Schickling wrote on Nov. 5 that the firm found little evidence AI is the main reason new grads are struggling.
What Vanguard found
- In the jobs most exposed to AI, employment among recent graduates is close to pre-pandemic levels. For grads ages 22 to 26, it's only modestly below its normal trend.
- The bigger shortfall is in jobs with medium AI exposure, and that weakness started before ChatGPT launched in late 2022.
- Companies best positioned to benefit from AI have actually out-hired other firms since then, and their hiring edge is biggest among workers ages 22 to 26.
Vanguard mapped AI's abilities to about 800 occupations and compared hiring at large employers using its 401(k) recordkeeping data.
So what is going on?
Vanguard points to a "low-fire, low-hire" job market. Companies aren't laying off many people, but they aren't adding many either. Young people trying to land their first job depend on new hiring, so they feel a slowdown first.
That matches the broader data. Monthly job gains have averaged about 68,000 this year, the Associated Press reported, well below the 2023–2024 pace. October was stronger, with 165,000 jobs added.
Vanguard also noted that employers have long-term reasons to keep hiring young workers, such as replacing retirees and building their next generation of mid-career talent.
Our take: If you're a recent grad, the problem may be fewer openings, not that a machine took your spot. Widen your search to employers that are adding staff, use internships and contract work to get a foot in the door, and learn the AI tools in your field; Vanguard found the companies best positioned to use AI have been the most eager to hire young workers.
Sources: Vanguard: What's behind young workers' job struggles? · Associated Press via ABC11 · Our standards
Get the morning briefing
The news, with receipts. Free, every morning.


