Skip to content
Mane Newsroom
Breaking

Atlanta OKs Demolition of the House at the Center of a Landmark Gay Rights Case

Michael Hardwick's 1982 arrest at the Ponce de Leon Place home led to a Supreme Court fight that shaped LGBTQ+ history.

By Mane Newsroom Staff

Published

The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington on a clear dayLifestyle
The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington on a clear day. Photo: Sunira Moses / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

An Atlanta house tied to one of the most consequential gay rights cases in U.S. history may soon be torn down.

The city's Zoning Review Board voted Nov. 5 to approve an application to demolish 811 Ponce de Leon Place NE, Rough Draft Atlanta reported. The owners, Paul and Penny Gutierrez, plan to build a new home with a pool.

Why the house matters

In 1982, an Atlanta police officer entered the home and arrested Michael Hardwick under Georgia's sodomy law for having sex with another man. Hardwick challenged the law.

In 1986, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled 5-4 against him in Bowers v. Hardwick, upholding the law. The court reversed itself in 2003 with Lawrence v. Texas, which struck down laws criminalizing private, consensual intimacy between adults of the same sex. Hardwick died in 1991.

The case for tearing it down

The owners' lawyer, Stephen Rothman, told the board that fixing the house would cost more than replacing it, citing black mold and poor renovations. He said a remodel around 2016, which added a second story and enclosed the porch, left little of the 1982 structure.

The push to save it

  • On Nov. 2, the Atlanta City Council unanimously asked the city's Urban Design Commission to consider the property for landmark status. The resolution was a request, not a designation.
  • More than 90 LGBTQ+ advocates and residents signed a letter urging the board to deny or delay the demolition.
  • The site is listed in Atlanta's 2023 LGBTQ+ Historic Context Statement, though that listing doesn't protect it on its own.

Board members said there wasn't enough reason to keep holding up the owners while the landmark question remained unresolved.

What's next

If city planners formally pursue a landmark nomination, demolition would be paused during a review of 120 to 180 days, Rough Draft reported. The owners have said they're open to a historical marker near the site.

Sources: Rough Draft Atlanta · The Advocate · Our standards

Get the morning briefing

The news, with receipts. Free, every morning.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. We never sell your email.